From ‘Broken Windows’ to ‘It’s Just Snow’

Visible disorder and its implications

New York didn’t get more permissive by accident, it got there by choice — moving vending enforcement away from NYPD, legalizing needles, repealing the loitering law, then expressing surprise when public drug use and prostitution expanded.

In this episode, we talk with former cop and John Jay professor Peter Moskos, who recently published Back from the Brink, a book about the city’s crime fighting in the 1990, about the implications of higher tolerance for disorder that seem to be increasingly playing out from Washington Square Park to Roosevelt Avenue to the subway.

We get into the Washington Square snowball fight — which wasn’t really about snow but about where the city now draws the line on deploying cops, and what it signals when the mayor and the police commissioner land on opposite sides of that line in public.

We also talk about the NYPD staffing crisis and why the real problem isn’t whether the budget authorizes 5,000 more officers, but that the department struggles to hire faster than it loses people after a decade of anti-policing politics.

That leads to a conversation about Mayor Mamdani’s proposed Community Safety Department: why social-worker teams can’t actually replace police on dangerous calls, why they’ll end up as an expensive add-on, and what “success” would need to look like if the city insists on building it anyway.

Plus: a quiet, unheralded program that may actually be working on gun violence that nobody’s talking about.

If you want to understand how New York went from “broken windows” to “it’s just snow” — and what that means for parks, subways, shelters, and the neighborhoods that don’t get to opt out — this is an episode worth your time.

Please listen and subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts. Here are the links to Spotify and Apple, and you can always find them under the podcasts tab.